BiS Strict 10 Prot Paladin Gear List

19 January 2010 - 4 Responses

Alas, I have returned to college after the winter break and am thusly without access to actually raiding in World of Warcraft during the week, which means I’ll have to refocus my obsession on other venues, such as the fantastic Profiler on Wowhead.com. I recently created my account over at Wowhead and I’ve been nothing less than impressed with the ability to gem, enchant, and fully deck out a model of any class and race. As I was tooling around regemming Poetry’s gear, I decided it would be helpful to create a best in slot list of gear for my current raiding situation, strict 10-man. At this point in time, Heroic Icecrown 10 is unavailable so I’ll leave heroic gear off the list for now. I’ll make a heroic BIS list once the stats are finalized, namely the sockets/socket bonuses.

The list assumes Jewelcrafting/Enchanting (my picks for BIS professions) and the well-loved 0/53/18 spec. Special attention was paid to maintaining the Expertise soft cap as exactly as possible and only matching 9/12 stam bonuses. For the purposes of matching sockets, Shifting Dreadstones go in red and Enduring Eye of Zuls go in yellow. (Note: if you’re a stickler for hit, you can replace the Enduring Eye of Zuls with Vivid, at a loss of avoidance.)

Click here for the link to the gloriously visualized Wowhead profile.

I Live!

29 November 2009 - Leave a Response

NaNo is over! AWMGUH, I have free time again. I have no idea what I’m going to do with it all. (No, I do: Dragon Age: Origins. Trufax.)

Anyways, I’ve been busy in WoW over the extended break. Faction changed and server transferred one of my 3 druids to Horde/Sentinels to level and play with my super awesome friends, and I hit 80 on that toon a few days ago. For those of you keeping score at home, I now have an 80s roster that consists of paladin paladin priest mage druid druid shaman hunter. Yeah. I have 8 80s now. I’ll work on a 9th over winter break, for sure.

I discovered that I hate feral at low gear levels because the severe lack of crit means half my dots are falling off all the time and… I have almost no ArPen. D: It’s terrible, I know.

NaNo is over, like I mentioned. National Novel Writing Month (NaNoWriMo) was absolutely spiffy. I “won”, which means I successfully wrote a 50k+ word novel in the time span from November 1st to the 30th. My final word count was 51,755. December is National Novel Editing Month now… that should be fun. At least it won’t be near as “write or die” as November was. Overall, I’m pleased that I finished book two of three and I look forward to writing book three sometime early next summer.

In WoW, I actually have stuff to do now. I can hop on heroic trains and start farming up tons of badges again, and thankfully this time someone has an alt to join me in the fun. My awesome friend Thelonius is going to gear up his tanky pally while I gear up my tree durid and we’ll run all the heroics and skip through fields of flowers together and all that fun stuff. Good times. Poetry is going to have to hang out and wait, I guess. I might do some more lawlrp with her, but I still can’t take that seriously enough to invest time into seeking out RP and things like that. On a related note, a friend of mine named his death knight “Srsrpname”, and that just about describes our feelings on RP. It’s fun, sure, but we’re still in the stage where it’s just hilarious to us that we’re actually coming up with stories for our characters. I won’t be RPing with the durid, I know that. I like the story of Warcraft, and writing RP segments for Poetry is actually a very good writing exercise so I’m sure I’ll come up with something.

That being said, winter break should be extremely productive. Badge farming is great fun for me when I’m doing it with a group of my closest friends, and now we’ve gotten a few back from their extended breaks from the game, I’m really excited to get back into things and tear it up like we used to. My friends are what this game is all about for me. (And the ridiculously sexual man-love that takes place in Ventrilo. It’s called bromance for a reason, folks.<3)

Icewell Radiance

29 October 2009 - 3 Responses

Allow me to quote Ghostcrawler on this:

For Icecrown Citadel, we are implementing a spell that will affect every enemy creature in the raid. The spell, called Chill of the Throne, will allow creatures to ignore 20% of the dodge chance of their melee targets. So if a raid’s main tank had 30% dodge normally, in Icecrown Citadel they will effectively have 10%.”

What. The. Hell.

Seriously? And here I was thinking Blizzard would have learned their lesson from Sunwell and fixed their mistake for Icecrown. No, sadly, they’ve made the exact same mistake again. Let me break this down for you. Let’s use Varuk from EJ’s average buffed avoidance of a main tank and work through these numbers. Since the 20% from Icewell Radiance is post-DR, this means the same rating that takes your avoidance from 70% to 70.5% now will take you from 50% to 50.5% after the nerf. 70-70.5 is a 1.66% reduction in damage taken, 50-50.5 is a 0.99% reduction in damage taken. (0.99 / 1.66) = ~60%. This is a 40% nerf to avoidance. WHAT IN THE CRAP.

I can hear the anguished wails of healers everywhere, and any of you healers saying “cool, less spike damage, less ‘dodge or die’ scenarios” clearly never healed Brutallus. Let me tell you from experience: you miss a heal, the tank dies. You hesitate a fraction of a second, the tank dies, and this is with 3-5 main tank healers (Paladins) all chain-casting Holy Light. Brutallus was bullshit, and it looks like Icecrown will be too. The only thing at this point that even matters on gear is armor and stamina. You need to stack absolutely retarded levels of stamina to even survive two hits in a row because you sure as hell will be taking them. This is ALMOST as bad as crushing blows on Sacrolash, and I only saw “almost” because crushing blows was  a stupid mechanic, but that’s a different ballgame.

Basically, in Icecrown, screw avoidance. Screw dodge, screw parry, screw ‘em. Ignore every single socket bonus because if it’s not a 30 stam gem, it’s bad. Unless this stupid debuff (or rather, enemy mob buff) also lessens the severity of diminishing returns (which it probably won’t, because it’s on the mobs and not us), avoidance is now worth just about as much as shield block/rating. We’re seriously going to be running with Naxxramas-level defensive values. I hope to all that is holy that Blizzard at least gives us high stam and high armor pieces in Icecrown because we’re going to need it.

Blizzard said after Sunwell, “We don’t want tanks to have incredibly high avoidance moving forward into Wrath”, and uh, that worked out well for them, right? In fact, they just said the exact same thing in almost the exact same words when they announced this new mechanic. So they toss in Icewell Radiance to “fix” the problem, and they break it all over again. They said they didn’t like how high avoidance was getting. Fine. Nerf the amount of rating per percent like you did haste and everyone will be fine. I’d honestly prefer that solution. The way they are proposing it now means more damage taken per second, and don’t kid yourself if you think they’re going to reduce how much damage bosses hit for. No chance. And what does this get them for their trouble? They had said they wanted to move towards “less inflated tank health pools” which ALSO isn’t going to work, because we’re going to NEED high health pools just to be able to take multiple hits in a row. I guess this just flip-flops tanking stat priority. Everything that’s not stamina will be terrible, so stack the crap out of it and hope you have good healers.

PS: Grats druids, you’re now the best tank class in the game. Don’t believe me? See here.

Letter to Rilgon

27 October 2009 - 5 Responses

I wrote this to Rilgon of Stabilized Effort Scope as an explanation of some of my views on the discussion regarding “hybrid” versus “pure” classes. It’s pretty rough and the language is definitely not pretty, but I thought perhaps some of you would be interested in reading it. Contrary to popular belief, no, I do not hate pure DPS classes, as I rather fully explained in the following letter. The link to Ghostcrawler’s official word on the “Hybrid tax” may be found here. If you haven’t, you should read it before reading the rest of this post.

This was too long to comfortably post in Twitter, so READY SET GO

I totally agree with Ghostcrawler. As a paladin, yes, I can tank and heal in addition to DPS. Should I be able to trounce pure DPS classes? Hell to the fuck no. Should I be competitive enough that I won’t be a hindrance to the raid if I choose to come as Ret? Yes, absolutely. Should I bring buffs/procs that make up for my lower DPS? Yes, absolutely. Should a better geared/skilled hybrid DPS be able to out-do a poorly geared/skilled pure DPS? Yes, absolutely. Given exactly equal stats/skills/what-have-you, on a tank-and-spank, yes, a hybrid should be doing about a grand or so less DPS on average. If I peg a hunter at ~11k dps, I would expect to see hybrids sitting in the mid to high 9s. 9k DPS is still astounding, but I shouldn’t be able to mop the floor with rogues/mages/hunters/whatever.

I think a lot of attention should be paid to “Player skill, gear, raid comp, latency, random luck and most importantly the specifics of the encounter will often favor one class, spec or player over another.” Could this mean a hybrid could out-DPS a pure? Sure, given fight mechanics or whatever. But on the other side of that, let’s consider a movement-heavy fight. Survival hunters, lol sorry bros, kiss Sniper Training goodbye. The Ret pallies are going to out-do you on this fight. BUT. I still think “all things being equal”, as he says, that rogues should be squashing both Ret pallies AND Survival hunters in that fight. That’s just a side effect of stupid-ass fight mechanics (sup faction champs), so there’s not much we can do about that.

The last point he makes I really liked. “In general, we ask that players focus their feedback more on class mechanics and what is fun or not fun about the classes and not simply on “My dps is too low so you must buff me.”” My issue with a lot of pure DPS classes is that I hear “QQ X class is better than me and they’re a hybrid, wahh, buff class Y”. That shit pisses me off. Sure, a flat number/percentage increase to certain abilities to bring them into line makes sense sometimes, but I would like to see more reasons to bring certain classes as a DPS increase for the raid, too. Things like Bloodlust, Trueshot Aura, Paladin auras, Sheeping (er, lol, bad example but stick with me); I think every class should have *one (or two) thing(s)* that makes having one of each absolutely essential to a raid, far and above what their spec happens to be. That is, all shammies can Bloodlust regardless of spec. Needs more of that. Beyond sick-nasty DPS, I still think pure DPS classes should each have something fuck-awesome that they bring to a raid. Maybe give TSA to all hunters and gives Marks something else, OR give a unique aura to all three hunter specs. Something like that. At any rate, give every single class something that makes them attractive (BESIDES HUGE NUMBERS) that makes raid leaders want them in their raid, regardless of spec.

Rogues are always in the forefront of my thoughts when I read discussions about stuff like this. Rogues don’t bring any buffs to the raid. They’ve got… Kick. That’s about it. Given Blizzard’s earlier logic (lower dps + really cool buffs, OR high dps + sorta cool buffs) that puts rogues at OMGWTFBBQDPS. Now, let’s say your DPS meters for a boss fight look like this:

1. Rogue               (13k DPS)
2. Hunter             (11k DPS)
3. Warlock          (11k DPS)
4. Ret Pally         (9k DPS)
5. DK                      (9k DPS)

I’m totally cool with that chart. Rogues don’t have any buffs, they should be WAY high up there. Hunters/warlocks have auras, curses, proc effects, other utilities and whatever, so that places them a little bit lower. The hybrids are towards the bottom, but not lagging far behind. However, in this scenario, the hunter and warlock are going to throw a shit fit that they’re being out-DPSed by an order of 2k dps. That is NOT going to fly with other pure dps classes, so Blizzard either buffs hunters/warlocks or nerfs rogues. Neither of those solutions is good. The community doesn’t understand that hunters and warlocks bring things to the raid that rogues do not, so they should naturally be a little bit lower on the charts. So they bitch and they moan and there are arguments and everything, and at the end of the day, no forward progress is made. You can’t explain to the community, “But rogues are fine doing ridiculous DPS because it’s all they really do” because 11 out of 10 WoW forum-goers are too fucking retarded to understand that.

What Blizzard needs to be working on (and I hope for chrissakes that they do for Cataclysm) is giving every class something that explains why they’re in a given position on average DPS meters. If they need to give (using the rogue example) rogues something that brings their DPS down but makes up for it in raid buffs or whatnot, they could make talents like Turn The Tables or Honor Among Thieves not affect the rogue, but grant a buff to the raid, Ferocious Inspiration/Elemental Oath style. As it stands now, that’s their only choice because they obviously can’t explain to the community the logic I just presented you. That’s not a slight on them, but rather on a misinformed/douchebag community.

NaNoWriMo, or Where Did My November Go?

26 October 2009 - Leave a Response

This is a bit rambly and not in any way beneficial to the average reader, so you can skip this one if you like.

I just wanted to drop a quick line to let everyone know I’m participating in NaNoWriMo this year. Since most of you are already familiar with what that is, you can understand that my November will pretty much be toast. I’ll be writing furiously the entire month and pretty much the last thing I’ll want to do is blog here after finishing NaNo’s ~2,000 required words for the day. I’ll pop in occasionally to provide status updates and let everyone know I’m not dead.

I’ve been writing for giggles for about a year now. I don’t write Warcraft fiction, sorry, so it won’t be posted here. I’m a rabid Star Wars fan and I fancy myself a Star Wars historian. “Lore nerd” doesn’t even begin to cover it. Since everything Star Wars (the books, the movies, the comics, most of the video games) is considered canon, EVERYTHING is lore. If it is published and bears the Lucasarts seal of approval, it is canonical. That means there’s a couple *thousand* sources of information from which to glean information and I’ve read just about all of them. (No seriously, I have. Five full-size bookshelves and counting.)

Anyways, I’ve always wanted to write… something. Anything. Short stories just don’t really cut it for me. I need insane depth and breadth with my fiction, something that Warcraft can’t give me, so I can’t comfortably write in the Warcraft universe. Not that I would want to write in the Warcraft universe, but I must stop myself before I digress further. Instead, I write in the Star Wars universe. I live and breathe Star Wars (you should see my dorm room and my entire frakking house, good grief) and it has always been my first and true passion. So, my NaNo novel this year is actually going to be a continuation of a series of novels I’ve been working on for a year now. I started book one around the end of the summer before my senior year of high school and wrote casually during school. Book one is sitting pretty at around 62,000 words (240 pages) right now. I’m going to write book two for NaNo this year. I haven’t done NaNo before, but since I don’t play WoW at school, I should have oodles of time to write. Plus, NaNo gives me an excuse to write like a madman for a month and I intend to use the momentum from NaNo to keep writing on a regular basis after November is over.

I didn’t want it to be a complete surprise when I inevitably don’t manage to get any real posts out during the entire month of November. Instead, I’d like to open this up as an opportunity for anyone to suggest guides, discussions, number-crunching, or any other in-depth articles they would like me to write. The babytank guide was a pretty big hit among the people who had requested it, so for those of you that would like to see a particular guide, the comments are open.

Tankadin 101 with Professor Poetry

22 October 2009 - 10 Responses

Table of Contents: (click to jump to a section)

So your baby tanky pally just hit level 80 and you’re faced with the daunting prospect of tanking instances that, for the first time, are pretty much serious business. You’re looking to hit up lolheroics to collect heaps and piles of lolemblems for your first pieces of shiny new epics. Pull up a chair and get out your notebooks. Welcome to Tankadin 101. Class will begin after the jump.

Read the rest of this entry »

Poetry’s View, Part 1: The Horde

11 October 2009 - Leave a Response

I wanted to post a short overview of Poetry’s views of the various races that comprise the Horde, as well as the political organization of the Horde itself.

The Horde

> As far as a political structure goes, Poetry understands the necessity of the Horde. For the blood elves, it’s an alliance of convenience and that works for her. She respects Thrall as a leader. Though she distrusts most orcs, Thrall has proven to her that he is an honorable and wise leader in the face of strife and instability. She respects Cairne Bloodhoof’s wisdom and his unique ties to nature as a member of the tauren. His long life has demonstrated his ability to make decisions for the good of his people even if those decisions are tough. She admires his resilience in helping his people recover from almost being wiped out. Poetry doesn’t have much contact with Vol’jin, so she is rather ambivalent regarding his leadership. She feels he is almost a figurehead for the trolls and nothing more. Sylvanas is one of Poetry’s closest political allies and therefore commands an intense respect. Poetry feels that Sylvanas is on a justified crusade given her history, and is envious of her deep personal strength. It goes without saying that she has a close personal relationship with Lor’themar Theron, given her political status. They are close friends and she believes he has an admirable vision for the future of her people.

The Orcs

> It should be noted that Poetry isn’t necessarily a racist. She reserves judgment to be placed upon the individual based on their deeds and words, not the deeds and words of their race. That being said, she instinctively distrusts most orcs given their history. She feels that being tainted by fel magic and rage has irreparably damaged the orcs as a race, rendering them weak. Poetry thinks that the individual members of the orc clans must work extremely hard to prove themselves to the other members of the Horde, and therefore often treats orcs harshly and impolitely until they manage to earn her trust. She demands the most from the orcs when it comes to her giving an individual her trust and friendship.

The Trolls

> The trolls thoroughly confuse Poetry. They’re hospitable and steadfast friends, but their berserker rage and bloodthirst are wholly frightening. She hasn’t needed to spend an extensive amount of time in troll territory, but during the visits she has made to their villages and outposts she has been greeted with kindness and unmatched hospitality. She has witnessed the intensity and fury of trolls in combat, and worries that they sometimes let their bloodlust and berserker rage cloud their mind and judgment. Poetry maintains casual but friendly relations with Vol’jin and his tribe.

The Tauren

> Poetry’s relations with the tauren are similar to those with the trolls. She hasn’t spent much time in tauren land but has nevertheless been treated with utmost courtesy. The tauren strike her as a somewhat naive race, with the exception of a few exceptional individuals. As a whole, the tauren Poetry has encountered are kind almost to a fault, and that worries Poetry. She also fears they don’t have a modern enough leadership to function properly in the political organization of the Horde. Cairne Bloodhoof hasn’t been very vocal in matters of war so Poetry often wonders exactly what the future of the tauren holds.

The Forsaken

> Poetry identifies well with the Forsaken. They are the only race that she feels can accurately identify with the sting of betrayal as keenly as the blood elves can. She has a very close relationship politically with Sylvanas and works to facilitate interaction between the Forsaken and the blood elves. Despite her awful memories of the undead scourge, she understands that only incredibly strong individuals maintain their sanity and are able to fight back the mindless plague. That, on a small scale, has already proven the character of most Forsaken in her eyes. She works constantly to help the Forsaken find an identity for their race, just as the blood elves have had to do on so many different occasions. She remains relatively confident in Sylvanas’ abilities to not let vengeance guide her judgment and decision-making but as the Horde grows closer to an assault on the Lich King, she begins to have her doubts.

The Sin’dorei

> Poetry is immensely proud of her people’s tenacity and perseverance. They have survived multiple betrayals and leadership upheavals without crumbling and Poetry thinks they are the strongest of the races because of this. She doesn’t view the blood elves that defected to support Kael’thas as members of her own race anymore. They are lesser beings in her eyes. She is always impressed with Lor’themar Theron’s leadership given the circumstances of his rule and therefore works faithfully for him as a show of solidarity and of friendship. Her people have suffered in the face of imminent defeat many times and have emerged victorious. Poetry is immovably loyal to Silvermoon and Quel’danas and works as a member of the Shattered Sun and the Blood Knights to show her pride and dedication to the cause of the Sin’dorei.

Ambassador Poetry, a History

8 October 2009 - Leave a Response

I’ve been playing Dungeons and Dragons for (Now that I think about it, it has been ten years. Scary.) close to ten years now , so I can pull backstory out of nowhere when needed. However, I figured it was soon time to start writing some things down. Now that I’ve moved to Sentinels, I have an actual outlet for my need to RP as Poetry on a (fairly) regular basis.

> Born to a quiet couple in Dawnstar Village, Poetry was a bouncing baby high elf girl with curious forest-green eyes. Born to an accomplished Magister and an agile Farstrider scout, Poetry spent much of her early years quietly learning to read with her mother Athena under the shade of the majestic oaks behind the family villa. When she reached the age of twenty-five, her father Artisan (by name, not by trade) began to take her along to Magisters’ Terrace, grooming her to follow him in the mage’s path of mastery of the arcane. Ever-curious, she spent much of her time finding ways to slip away from her father and watch the boats come in to port at Sun’s Reach Harbor. Poetry also became enamored with the Sunwell’s radiance, and ate most of her lunches with her father in the western courtyard.

> To her father’s dismay and her mother’s delight, Poetry never had much talent with arcane magic. She found it brash, coarse, and lacking grace. Her father was shocked by this discovery and began to distance himself from her as her mother began teaching her the art of literature, painting, and ironically enough, poetry. Poetry studied the liberal arts diligently for years until she was old enough to take the entrance exam for Silvermoon’s premiere political science academy. She excelled on the exam and her studies at the academy, enough so to earn her an internship with Prince Kael’thas’ political staff. She served as apprentice to an elderly scholar named Anester up until the time of the Second War, when she found herself asked to serve with the advisory staff in the field during the war on the undead forces.

Life of adventuring

> With a recent graduation from Silvermoon’s own political science academy and a place in Kael’thas’ retinue of advisors, Poetry was sent to parlay with Lord Garithos for the release of and dismissal of execute-on-sight warrants against Kael’thas and his troops following Kael’s acceptance of help from Lady Vashj and the naga. This would also be her first experience with the sweltering amount of legal red tape, as she never reached Garithos himself. Instead, she ran headfirst into his retinue of advisors and never delivered the missive to Garithos, but it would prove inconsequential as Kael had already escaped from the Dalaran prisons with Vashj’s help. This particular encounter was her first step out into the world. (…… of Warcraft.)

> Returning to Anester empty-handed and feeling like a failure, he comforted her and told her he would begin looking for Kael’thas at once. However, Anester’s scrying returned no results, as Kael’thas had already ported to the Outlands with Lady Vashj. Anester, troubled by this absence, quickly penned a report for Poetry to deliver back to Silvermoon. On her way back to the city, she learned that the advisory council in the field was attacked by undead forces near Dalaran. With Garithos’ removal of the Alliance’s military aid, the entire party had been slaughtered at the hands of the undead. Fighting back tears, she made her way back to Silvermoon, delivered the missive to the Sunfury Spire wordlessly, and collapsed in her home on Quel’danas.

> Even indirectly witnessed, the merciless slaughter wrought by the undead shocked Poetry. Her mother urged her to seek out a path that would allow her to right the wrongs of the war and aid the victims that were needlessly suffering. Poetry made up her mind and returned to Silvermoon to pledge her services to the Church of Light. She trained there as a healer, learning to mend the wounds suffered by high elves in the field fighting the undead.

> Fast forward a few decades. An accomplished healer and court politician, Poetry served as Lady Liadrin’s representative to the other high elven organizations. She met often with her mother Athena, now a Farstrider ranger commander, on official business as liason to the Farstrider Enclave. Her father joined the High Nethermancer of the Magisters’ Terrace, Zerevor, in the high elven armed forces. Both Poetry and her mother would see less and less of Artisan as his duties in the field prevented him from returning home often.

> With the capture of M’uru and the creation of the Blood Knights, Lady Liadrin approached the members of the Church of Light, specifically calling upon the priests and priestesses to join her in the fledgling order of paladins. Poetry, influenced by the teacher and friend she found in Liadrin, took up arms with her as a Blood Knight. She was initially uncomfortable with draining the power from another being but she felt subconsciously that M’uru was secretly at peace with events, and so, she trained diligently with her sword and shield, travelling all across Azeroth to hone her skills. She began to meet the member races of her new allies, the Horde. The tauren awed her with their mastery of the natural world. The trolls and orcs frightened her with their seemingly barbaric and brutal customs. The Forsaken held a special place in her heart once they told her of their similar betrayal by the Alliance, and she began to rapidly forge friendships with notable Forsaken contacts all over Azeroth. This eventually led to her proposal of a formal confederacy with Silvermoon to the leader of the Undercity, the Lady Sylvanas, an ally of her mother’s. As her skills as a paladin grew, so did her knowledge of the Forsaken and her prowess as a negotiator and ambassador to the races of the Horde.

((Forgive me for being so brief here, but this section covers levels 1-80 in-game, and since we’ve all seen it, I don’t feel the need to explain it again. I’ll probably touch on specific events during this time in little ficlets in the future.))

> With the secession of Kael’thas from Silvermoon proper, Poetry’s father was asked to join his superior, High Nethermancer Zerevor, in the Illidari Council situated in the dread fortress now known as the Black Temple. Zerevor did not want to lose such a crucial supporter to Kael’thas’ growing popularity. Upon Artisan’s refusal, Zerevor attacked him in a fury, initiating an arcanists’ duel that left both combatants disfigured and badly injured but ultimately claimed her father’s life. When the new reached Silvermoon, her mother was heartbroken, distraught, and enraged. Poetry called upon her mother’s closest friends at the Farstrider Enclave but by that time, Athena had already broken down. Poetry accompanied her mother back to Eversong, where she situated her in Fairbreeze Village to live under the close watch of her dearest friends. Poetry herself dealt with the death of her father quite well. By this point, she is no stranger to war, betrayal, and loss. Her mother hasn’t said much since the day she found out about her husband’s death, and rarely leaves Fairbreeze. Poetry always visits her when she passes through Silvermoon and often brings her mother tiny trinkets and keepsakes from her travels.

Life at level 80.

> Poetry currently works for the Regent Lord Lor’themar Theron as the Silvermoon City consular to the Undercity. She maintains close ties with the Royal Apothecary Society and works to clear their name after the treachery of the former Grand Apothecary Putress. She maintains a permanent room in the residential quarters surrounding the Sunfury Spire. She continues to use her privileges as Ambassador to the Horde to smooth over misunderstandings and conflicts between the various races and political groups within the Horde. Since the death of her father, however, she has forsaken the healing arts and instead taken up a sword and shield, leading her allies into battle as an Ardent Defender of the Blood Knights.

Defiance vs Valiance vs Sacred Shield

6 October 2009 - Leave a Response

For reference:

Libram of Defiance

Libram of Valiance

Libram of the Sacred Shield (makes Libram of Obstruction obsolete)

I’ll be making these arguments from a main tank perspective, because that’s what I do. I’ll provide math wherever possible.

I strongly advocate using Valiance as a maintankadin and no one seems to understand why. For the sake of the math, I’ll be using my current dodge rating in my avoidance set and 0/53/18 spec which is 701 dodge rating, or 27.97% dodge.

Defiance provides a proc of 200 dodge rating, or 5.01% dodge before diminishing returns. Thanks to Theck’s scripting, we can model Defiance as having a 97.77% uptime, or a static dodge rating of (200 * .9777) = 196 dodge. With my current amount of dodge, 196 dodge rating is worth 2.81% dodge after diminishing returns. This is a far cry from the 5.01% before diminishing returns. In fact, Defiance is about (0.0281 / 0.0501) =  56.1% as effective as it could be. I’ve hit the ceiling in terms of dodge being amazingly effective as an avoidance stat. Giving consideration to DR, even Parry is an attractive stat by comparison. *shudders*

Valiance has become an extremely attractive threat libram based on the way it procs. It lasts 16 seconds and has an internal cooldown of 6 seconds. With a 70% chance to proc on SoV ticks, it maintains a ~97% uptime. (30% chance not to proc * 3 applicable ticks = 2.7% chance to fall off) This gives Valiance a static Strength bonus of 195 Strength before raid buffs. This makes Valiance a much better book than the BV ones for sure. Why? Strength affects every single one of our threat abilities in multiple ways, while BV only affects one. Strength boosts damage – white and yellow – across the board. With the change to Touched by the Light, 60% of our Strength gets rolled into Spell Power. Physical and Holy damage are the staples of our threat generation from damaging abilities. A gain in Strength also delivers a gain in Spell Power, so our threat abilities get to double dip from Valiance. Additionally, assuming 5/5 in Divine Strength and 3/3 in Redoubt, this Strength proc provides 195 * 1.15 = 224 / 2 = 112 * 1.30 = 145.6 BV. LoO gives 352 and LotSS gives 450. However, block is all but useless on bosses. BV affects only one of our threat abilities while Strength (and spell power, as per above) affect all of them. Besides, the ~300 BV lost can be made up for with higher armor pieces, if you’re that concerned about mitigation. The fact that Valiance gives BV at all is merely icing on the cake.

The only reason I would ever consider using a BV libram is for heroics and trash. Don’t get me wrong, Sacred Shield is still a good bench libram for that kind of thing, but I almost never do either. In fact, I would still use Valiance purely from a personal DPS perspective while tanking heroics. It’s anecdotal, but I can manage almost 3000 dps in heroics.

The great thing about librams is that you can grab a couple and swap them out for different fights. Personally, I’d go with Defiance for hard modes and “hits-like-a-train-driven-by-Saurfang-and-Hellscream” and Valiance for farm content, adds tanking, and DPS races. The more threat you can pump out per unit time means your DPS has a higher ceiling to shoot for. This means Arcane mages can bust out their highest DPS rotation, Hunters can FD less, and the like. The quicker your DPS can open up and the harder they can open up when they do, the faster shit dies. I’m not saying Valiance is a solution to threat problems by any means. If you have threat problems you probably have other issues. Instead, I’m pointing out that you can help the DPS out by pumping out more threat whenever possible. For example, my notoriously threat-happy Hunter and Warrior friends can unload at the same time as me on Jaraxxus adds and I have no problem hanging on, and on top of that, my own DPS contribution isn’t too shabby.

TL;DR Get both Defiance and Valiance. Use Defiance for the hard stuff, Valiance for the easy stuff, and if you’re using a BV libram for any other reason than to remain at the 102.4% unhittable cap, then you have more problems than I can address in this post.

(PS: You can pretty easily hit 102.4 with a normal avoidance set and Holy Shield. That eliminates the need for a BV libram almost entirely.)

Real Life *crits* Guild

14 September 2009 - One Response

For those of you following my Twitter, you’ve heard snippets of what happened to my guild over the past few days. I’d like to sum it up and catch everyone up on how my guild imploded in less than a week.

First, one of my officers hadn’t logged on in about a week. He’s in graduate school for music performance, so that’s not too out of the ordinary for the start of semester. The day before he was last seen, we had an extremely productive raid night. Mimiron and General three- and one-shot, respectively. XT Hard Mode was two-shot for the first time as well. Freya Hard Mode got down to a 13% wipe before we decided to just kill her and move on. Hodir Hard Mode missed by less than 15 seconds. Like I said, an extremely productive night.

Everyone logged off after a few peeks at Yogg. Fast forward two weeks, and we hadn’t since stepped back into Ulduar. None of my raiders wanted to log on without giving a particular reason why. It became evident that our GM and his two brothers were taking an extended break from the game without saying anything to me about it. One by one, my raiders started getting cherry-picked by other guilds – as our server is wont to do – and my raid team was falling apart. A few nights ago, the GM finally admitted he was taking a month or two break. He logged into the game, informed me of this in a single tell, and promoted my toon to Guild Master before logging back off. Guild chat was deadly silent when this happened.

In the past few days since this has happened, I lost another two of my core raiders. Our regular 10-man group is down to about 6 people now. I’m frantically trying to salvage the situation by organizing the remaining members and trying to recruit. Recruiting is all but futile on my server, as we are extremely low population. I’ve been mulling over changing the guild name for a few reasons:

There are 99 toons in the current guild. They are 90% composed of alts of ex-members and current members alike. Seeing as I have about 8 active members now, that’s a lot of cleaning house that needs to be done.

A lot of the members who left made it public that they were from Dodecahedron (our current guild name) and that has generated a lot of negative press connotation around our name.

It’s simply easier from an organizational standpoint to take the active members and their alts and move to a new name for a fresh start and as an added bonus, I can more easily keep track of my raid roster.

The whole experience has been a mixed blessing because now I know which members are diehard and dedicated to the progression of our group. We’re easily capable of a Yogg+0 (which would be a server first) and eventually Algalon (also a server first). My only qualm about grabbing my raiders and moving is that I don’t want the (now ex-) GM to see it as an attack on his authority. I don’t want it to look like I sniped his raid group out from under him and ran. That’s not the case at all. I don’t like to think of it as his guild, or my guild, or anyone’s guild. When it comes down to it, it’s OUR guild, and I intend to reinforce that message. I just think that we need a fresh start and a proverbial do-over after suffering such catastrophic losses. I’ll be in touch with my one remaining officer over the next few days and provide updates to Twitter, and I thank those of you for your continued support.